Skip to content

The Hard Conversation: Mental Health

Three sessions of one-word answers. What now?

This week's conversation

He is 31, a shift supervisor at a distribution centre, referred through his employer's assistance programme after a heated argument with a colleague. The first session went well enough. He talked about the night shifts, his sleep, his little girl.

Then three sessions of this. "How was the week?" "Fine." "Anything come up with work?" "Not really." "What was that like?" A shrug. He arrives on time. He sits with his jacket on. He looks at the clock about twenty minutes in.

You have tried open questions, scaling questions, a worksheet. Each one gets a word or two. The moment you dread is the next silence, when you can feel yourself reaching for another question just to make it stop.

Why it goes sideways

The mechanism here is mostly ours, not his. Silence feels like failure, so we fill it. Each unanswered question raises our anxiety, and we answer it with a new question. Motivational interviewing calls this the question-answer trap: the clinician asks, the client gives the shortest possible reply, and the session turns into an interview the client is quietly declining to sit.

The more we ask, the more control sits with us, and the more passive he becomes. For someone who arrived through his employer, that can feel like being assessed. Short answers may be the safest thing he has. They are information, not a dead end. The way out is fewer questions, more reflections, and saying out loud what is happening between you.

What to say

To open, name the pattern with curiosity, not complaint:

"I've noticed that for a few weeks a lot of my questions get a 'fine' or 'not really.' I'm not annoyed about that. I'm curious what it's like for you, sitting here with me asking them."

When he pushes back with "I don't know, I just don't have much to say":

"That's okay. You don't have to have much to say. I wonder if coming here feels more like something work sent you to than something you chose. If it does, that would make sense to me."

To close, turn any agreement into a small shared commitment:

"Here's what I'd suggest. Next week, you pick where we start, even if it's just the drive here. And if this isn't useful to you, I'd rather you tell me than keep sitting through it. Can we try that?"

  • Instead of "Can you tell me more about that?" try a reflection: "Sounds like that week took a lot out of you."
  • Instead of "Is something wrong?" try "I've noticed you've been quieter. I'm not sure what to make of it yet."
  • Instead of rushing to the next question after a pause, try waiting, then "Take your time. I'm not in a hurry."

If withdrawal comes with signs of hopelessness or risk, that is a different conversation. Assessment then follows your training, supervision and your setting's protocol.

Two-minute drill

Set a timer for two minutes. Say one of your usual session questions out loud. Then stay silent and count slowly to ten before you speak again. When you do, say a reflection, not a question. Repeat three times. Notice where in the count you feel the pull to fill the gap.

Practice it

Rehearse this before Thursday's session. On the free practice page, choose the Mental health domain and the "Withdrawn Client" persona, then describe the situation in a sentence; account holders can open "Three Sessions of One-Word Answers" by name from the app's library under Mental health → Silence & Withdrawal. Practice this conversation

The quiet is often where the work is.

— Dan

Dan Gardner, MD · Psychiatrist · Psychoanalyst · Founder, DialoQue

Get the next one

The Hard Conversation: Mental Health arrives every Thursday. Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.

Newsletters

One email a week per newsletter. Unsubscribe from each any time. See our privacy policy.

← All issues